Deandrea Hamilton
Editor
Turks and Caicos, January 25, 2025 – One man pulled the trigger but Police are looking for a group of people to hold responsible for the reckless Saturday, January 18 shooting of a popular dinner and nightclub in Providenciales. It led to the deaths of Dario Stubbs, a Turks and Caicos Islander and Shamone Duncan, an American tourist.
“In terms of the actual primary perpetrator – the gunman – it was one individual. However, our intelligence and further inquiries undoubtedly reveal that he was probably part of a wider group.”
Superintendent Dean Holden was addressing a live audience over Facebook and media in the room during a press event.
The information was shared in response to a line of questioning from the media as he shed some light on details of the probe.
Police do not believe the shooter entered the immediate area in a vehicle; he wanted to avoid CCTV detection and Police are convinced that it was a strategic dispatch of a dangerous hitman which ended horribly for two people completely unrelated to an ongoing beef.
“This is part of a wider criminal organisation and a network and connected to – what we think is – a potential dispute between organised crime groups. Some of which were probably socialising in that venue that night. The opposing gang knew that and that’s why they deployed a gunman to obviously eliminate them in terms of that feud,” said Dean Holden, TCI Police Superintendent and head of the Special Crimes Unit.
The shooter, with a high powered weapon, stood adjacent to the Grace Bay area lounge where the victims were struck. Pumping bullet after bullet, viciously and recklessly, it sent patrons scurrying for cover. It was a targeted attack which did everything but hit the mark, as the two murdered so senselessly were innocents described as being in “the wrong place at the wrong time.”
Up to publication time, no one had been arrested for the shocking shooting where three people were struck with bullets, but Superintendent Holden said the resources and tactics invested should change that, soon.
“We’ve committed quite significant investigative resources to that, only this morning we’ve held a briefing with US counterparts who are also providing investigative support.
So in terms of covering all the lines of inquiry in terms of forensics, ballistics, CCTV, intelligence development and other research and investigative methods, all that now has been comprehensively covered with support from the US and support from other departments in the TCI Police Force.”
Holden, who said he had reviewed the updates on the investigation on the morning of the press event, which was Wednesday January 22, did not shroud his reluctance to give details on the sensitive case.
“What I don’t want to do is divulge any specific lines of inquiry because to do so would potentially compromise future executive action. What I can say, having reviewed that investigation this morning, is that I am very confident now that we have a good understanding of the group that are involved in this attack and in the relatively near future I am very confident that we will be taking executive action with a view to bringing them to Justice.”
Duncan was a deputy at the Cook County Sheriff’s Office in Chicago and on vacation in Providenciales as part of a birthday celebration for her sister. Her entourage was on the balcony level of the lounge when the bullet struck, ending the party and her life.
Stubbs was a young father and husband, a professional working at TCI First Insurance. He had been picking up his wife from work, his daughter was with him when he was caught by a stray bullet.