By Dana Malcolm
Staff Writer
#TurksandCaicos, May 19, 2023 – The increases in the PNP’s historic $424 million budget are hidden in consultancy, utility, and normal salary inflation costs while programs and services to the people of the Turks and Caicos either remained the same or were directly cut sometimes by thousands of dollars; Edwin Astwood, Leader of the Opposition, was speaking in his response to the new budget.
Astwood maintained, on Wednesday, it is money residents won’t see directly.
“There are big jumps in utility and electricity costs, that is what the minister is bragging about. It isn’t programs, it isn’t money going directly to the people.”
Astwood, who had referred to the budget as a ‘Historic Budget of Constraints,’ found cuts in every ministry and department he shared during his response on May 17th. He said the size of the budget increased every year making them all ‘historic,’ but what was important was the amount of money going directly to the people. That is where he says this budget fails.
“I have seen budgets from former PDM and PNP Administrations provide far, far more for our people while being less in total expenditure. Previous administrations had a higher percentage of the budget going to the people, whereas this budget has almost nothing going directly to the people. The $424 million is the most ever in the overall total but the least ever percentage being spent directly on the people.”
In that vein, he listed what had increased and what had been cut for residents listening in. Astwood said decreases (in budgeted or actual spending) were recorded in: Community Policing; Social Welfare for the Police: Local Training for the Attorney General’s chambers and Deputy Governor’s office; Court Costs; Advertising for the Deputy Governor’s Office; Youth Activities for all schools’ Witness Protection (cut by half); Local Government Transformation; Ministry Travel; Youth Activities in the Youth Department; Cemetery Upkeep; the DMV; Travel, Rations, Maintenance and Social welfare in the Department of Corrections; the Works Program; Maintenance of Roads, fixed assets medical buildings; and public assets in the Ministry of PPID.
There were no decreases (or increases) awarded to the following: Training for police; Legal aid; Repatriation; Invest TCI; Street cleaning under PPID; Maintenance of Street Lights and Vehicles and Youth Activities in the Department of Heritage; Scholarships.
Astwood was incensed at the cuts and lack of increases he said, “We aren’t increasing scholarships? The position of our country today and how we need scholarships– there’s not one cent more in this historic $424 million budget with over $200 million in the bank?” he asked.
He said he was especially frustrated at the cuts and non-increases to youth programs.
“It’s much ado about nothing, nothing has changed. Everything is the same, no increase-” he said, referring to the Department of Heritage’s stagnant budget.
“That is saying that this money isn’t for our children – we have $424 million and $200 in the bank but our children, taking part in culture, you get nothing.”
Despite claims to the contrary, Green and Gender Budgeting are copiously missing from the budget according to Astwood. He expressed disdain at the $4,800 budgeted for Environmental Awareness Week.
“It’s just a catchphrase for you all. I don’t know if the Premier and Finance Minister knows what green budgeting is; from the allocations here, I have to draw that conclusion,” he said.
Astwood acknowledges increases in the following areas: National Celebrations; Home Help and Welfare; Consultancies in the Police Department, Immigration, Education, and Tourism. Utilities in the Judiciary; Home Affairs among others also increased. Daycare, After School Programs and Feeding Programs were new programs with significant allocations. Civil Servant costs increased across most departments.
E Jay Saunders, Finance Minister and Deputy Premier, had lambasted Astwood on Tuesday for disparaging his Budget, maintaining that they were spending more on the population than ever before.
“We are spending $135 million more on the people of our beautiful by nature Turks and Caicos Islands than has ever been spent prior to our government— if I’m wrong, tomorrow or today or whenever you come with your speech, please show me where we’re spending less,” he challenged.
Astwood responded to the claims, “We can’t be talking about the biggest budget ever and we’re here cutting and cutting— The Minister of Finance tried to make me out to be a teller of untruth– someone who is misleading the people but we can see it right here in front of us cuts, cuts, cuts!”
He maintained that he was committed to presenting the truth to TCI islanders as it was his job and he would continue to do so.
Listed are a non-exhaustive list of the actual figures itemised by the Leader of the Opposition as as read from the year’s budget book with decreases either from the Budgeted or actual spending in the last financial year:
Social Welfare (Police) $284 thousand (actual) down to $250 thousand
Local Training (Attorney General) $26 thousand down to $22 thousand
Court Costs (Judiciary $361 thousand down to $346 thousand
Advertising (Deputy Governor) $55 thousand down to $50 thousand
Local Training (Deputy Governor) $52 thousand down to $40 thousand
Youth Activities (HJ Robinson) $20 thousand down to $14 thousand
Youth Activities (Youth Department) $142 thousand down to $125 thousand
Witness Protection (Home Affairs) $54 thousand down to $21 thousand
Local Government Transformation $49 thousand down to $35 thousand
Cemetery Upkeep from $10 thousand down to $7,500
Travel (Dept of Corrections) $23 thousand down to $13 thousand
Rations(Dept of Corrections) $369 thousand down to $356 thousand
Maintenance (Dept of Corrections) $439 thousand down to $191 thousand
Social welfare (Dept of Corrections) $251 thousand down to $150 thousand
Works Program (PPID) $3.4 million down to $900 thousand
Maintenance of roads (PPID) $670 thousand down to $635 thousand
A non-exhaustive list of increases as quoted by Astwood included:
Consultancy (Judiciary) $2,000 up to $44 thousand
Consultancy (Immigration) $79 thousand up to $3.1 million
Local training (Immigration) $1,900 up to $3,185
Daycare (Education) new items
National Celebrations (Tourism) $177 Thousand up to $ 213 thousand
Home Help (Home Affairs) $1.5 million up to $1.6 million
Welfare (Home Affairs) $2.37 million up to $2.38 million
Welfare Grants (Home Affairs) $128 thousand up to $210 thousand